Fermentation Failures I’m Glad I Had (And What They Taught Me)
May 23 | Written By Sabrina Huizar
There’s nothing like the sound of a jar lid hissing open after a successful ferment—unless it’s the sound of your yogurt sloshing like runny milk or a sourdough starter bubbling with all the enthusiasm of a swamp.
I’ve had my fair share of fermentation wins. But let’s be honest: I’ve had plenty of flops too. Moldy kraut. Gassy kefir. Kombucha that went full rocket fuel.
Instead of tossing those experiences out with the curdled milk, I learned to keep them. Because every time a ferment failed, it handed me a lesson—about technique, patience, or just letting go.
So in the spirit of radical transparency (and microbial mischief), here are a few of my favorite fermentation flops—and the surprising wisdom they offered.
1. The Yogurt That Never Set
I did everything “right.” Heated the milk. Cooled it. Added the culture. Waited. And… nothing. Just slightly sour milk blinking up at me after 12 hours.
What it taught me:
Even cultures need a soft landing. I’d let my milk cool too far before inoculating, and my culturing temperature was all over the place. But it reminded me that yogurt isn’t fast food—it’s slow magic.
Next time, I swaddled the jar like a newborn and kept the temperature steady. It set like a dream.
Also? That “failed” batch made a killer smoothie base.
BONUS: I can’t tell you how many times I forgot to add the starter.
2. The Foreign Invader
There it was—my kombucha. My best batch yet. I could feel it. I open it up and leaned in, ready to admire my masterpiece… and then I saw it.
Something tangled in the pellicle. It looked suspiciously like a worm.
Cue panic. I stared at it for a solid five minutes before I dared go in. I was waiting for movement. Finally, I pulled it out—just a swollen rubber band.
What it taught me:
Double-check your setup. I still don’t know how that rubber band got in there, but the scare alone taught me to slow down, scan my workspace, and maybe breathe a little.
3. The Sourdough That Never Rose
I fed it. I whispered encouragement. I gave it time. Still, the dough stayed as dense as a doorstop. I baked it anyway. It had the texture of artisan concrete.
What it taught me:
That starter needed time. It had been neglected between bakes and needed consistent feedings to bounce back.
Also—ambition doesn’t speed up fermentation. Bread has its own clock, and it doesn’t care about your schedule.
4. The Kefir That Tried to Escape
I left a jar of milk kefir on the counter a bit too long in the peak of summer. When I opened it, the jar hissed, the grains looked mutinous, and the flavor? Let’s call it… spirited.
What it taught me:
Ferments are alive. And if you ignore them, they’ll throw a microbial rager without you.
Final Thoughts
Fermentation isn’t sterile. It’s messy, unpredictable, stubborn—and wildly rewarding. Each jar is a science experiment, a ritual, and a reminder to let go a little.
So if your yogurt flops, your sourdough sulks, or your kombucha smells like it might fight you—congrats. You’re fermenting with your hands, not just your eyes. And that’s where the real magic happens.
Stay tuned—and stay cultured.
—Sabrina
Milk Kefir Grains
from $15.00
Authentic Jun Starter Culture
from $15.00
